As promised...a follow up to last week's best actors born 1981-1990, here's my list of the ten best LIVING actors and actresses born between 1971 - 1980.
1980
Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams
This year was a tight fight between the guys, with Jake Gyllenhaal and Ben Foster both also contending for the win. Everyone knows him because of The Notebook, but ultimately, Ryan's performances in The Believer, Lars and the Real Girl and Half Nelson (for which he received an Oscar nomination), solidified my decision. Also watch his fantastic work in Remember the Titans, Murder by Numbers, and the upcoming film with Michelle Williams, Blue Valentine.
The only other female contender was Kristen Bell, and while I love her work, she hasn't quite proven to me that she can hang dramatically. Michelle got her big break as Jennifer on Dawson's Creek. Everyone knows this, but she has been able to do what the rest of the cast hasn't. She's thrown off the teenage soapy image, and really shown her acting chops. She received an Oscar nomination for her role in Brokeback Mountain, and was nominated again this year for Blue Valentine. She also starred alongside Leonardo DiCaprio in Shutter Island, as his wife, and did a turn of comedy with Kirsten Dunst in 1999's, Dick, about Nixon and Watergate.
1979
James McAvoy and Claire Danes
There were two other actors I considered here. The first, obviously, was Heath Ledger, but I decided to make this a list of living actors, so obviously Heath was out of the question. The other actor was Nick Stahl. Few people know him; he does lots of Indie movies, but his work has always been fantastic. However, I chose James because of his wide acting range. From the hit action movie, Wanted, to dramatic pieces like Atonement, The Last King of Scotland, and The Last Station, to the quirky Penelope, and his role as Tumnus in The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, he's shown he's got serious acting chops. He doesn't have an Oscar nomination yet, but he will.
Claire Danes was pretty much a shoe-in for me. The only other person I considered was Alison Lohman because of her performances in Matchstick Men and White Oleander. But I must confess that I am a Clare Danes fan through and through. From her early work in Little Women, My So-Called Life and Les Miserable to The Hours to Shopgirl, The Family Stone, Stardust and Evening, and now to her Golden Globe-winning performance of Temple Grandin, she's proven she can do just about anything.
1978
Gael Garcia Bernal and Rachel McAdams
I struggled a little with this year. I thought I'd give the award to James Franco because he did such a wonderful job portraying James Dean in the TV bio-pic, he was hilarious in Date Night, wonderful in Milk and got an Oscar Nomination for 127 Hours. But I changed my mind, and decided to give it to Gael. His work in The Motorcycle Diaries is brilliant, he played his role in Letter to Juliet to perfection, and he was also fantastic in Babel. I've always been pleased and impressed in every role I've seen him in.
Rachel, however, was pretty much a no-brainer from the beginning. Sure, you have January Jones who is brilliant in Mad Men, and Zoe Saldana who has exploded onto the scene in the last two years with Star Trek and The Losers. But Zoe's all action and no drama/comedy, and I honestly haven't seen enough of January Jones' work to judge. Rachel, however, has done comedy (Mean Girls, The Family Stone), thrillers (Red Eye, State of Play), romantic dramas (The Notebook, The Time Travelers Wife), action (Sherlock Holmes and its sequel) and an intimate character piece (The Lucky Ones). I've never seen a performance from her that I didn't like.
1977
Jonathan Rhys Meyers and Samantha Morton
Jonathan pretty much from the start, was my choice for this year. There was one contender in Edgar Ramirez, but I only considered him after searching through a list of actors born in 1977. Jonathan initially grabbed my attention as the coach in Bend It Like Beckham, and then again in Woody Allen's, Match Point. He won my heart in August Rush, kicked butt in From Paris With Love, won a Golden Globe for his portrayal of Elvis in the TV Movie, and has garnered tons of praise for his portrayal of Henry VIII in Showtime's The Tudors.
Samantha Morton is not well-known to most people, but she has been nominated for two Oscars, a SAG award and an Emmy, and won a Golden Globe (among many others). Her breakthrough performance for US audiences was in Minority Report. Her work is always spot on. She starred as Mary, Queen of Scots in Elizabeth: the Golden Age, as an Irish immigrant to America in In America, and as the widowed army wife in The Messenger...which is a brilliant movie.
1976
Ryan Reynold and Reese Witherspoon
Ryan has proven over the years, that while he really excels in comedy, he has the ability to play serious, dramatic roles. He got his start in the TV show Two Guys and a Girl, shines in comedies like The Proposal, Adventureland, and Just Friends, but has also done action (Blade: Trinity, X-Men: Origins, and The Green Lantern), horror (The Amityville Horror), a thriller (Buried), and the dramatic Fireflies in the Garden. Plus, he's not hard to look at.
Reese Witherspoon's one of those actresses who, I believe, could do anything. If you need her to play a tomboy, she can (Man in the Moon). If you need her to play a British character, she can (Vanity Fair, The Importance of being Earnest). If you need her to play an airhead, she can (Legally Blonde 1&2). If you need her to play some innocent ingenue, she's can (Cruel Intentions). If you need her to play someone completely unlikeable, she can (Election). If you need her to play a moped-riding eccentric, she can (Penelope). If you need her to play June Carter Cash, she can (Walk the Line), and do it so well she wins an Oscar.
1975
Tobey Maguire and Kate Winslet
Tobey was a pretty easy choice, especially since his performance in last years Brothers. But I've liked him for years, starting with the Spiderman trilogy, but also for his work in Seabiscuit, Pleasantville, Cider House Rules, and The Wonder Boys. Bradley Cooper, Hugh Dancy, and Casey Affleck were contenders, but they just don't quite have enough to convince me otherwise.
Kate Winslet, on the other hand had absolutely no challengers. Sure, there's Charlize Theron (who won and Oscar for Monster) and Marion Cotillard (who won and Oscar for La Vie en Rose). But Kate his received six Oscar nominations: For Sense and Sensibility, Titanic, Iris, Eternal Sunshine for the Spotless Mind, Little Children, and The Reader). She won in 2008 for The Reader, and should have been nominated in the same year for Revolutionary Road. Plus, she did wonderful films like Finding Neverland, and The Holiday. There is no one born in 1975 who comes close. She's absolutely brilliant in every role she takes, and I never feel like she's acting. She's that good.
1974
Leonardo DiCaprio and Hilary Swank
Leo's only competition was Christian Bale, who just won the Oscar this year. But, I had to give it to Leo. He's been nominated for 3 Oscars (What's Eating Gilbert Grape, The Aviator, Blood Diamond) but he could have easily been nominated for more, including his performances is Gangs of New York, Titanic, Revolutionary Road, and Catch Me If You Can. He's only made one or two movie missteps in his career, (The Beach, Man in the Iron Mask) and I'm happy to forgive him for them. I'd just like him to do a comedy...but the man is so serious, I doubt that will happen.
Hilary Swank was someone I almost didn't think about. She's won two Oscars (Boys Don't Cry, Million Dollar Baby) and they are well-deserved. But Amy Adams was born in 1976 as well (and has 3 Oscar nominations herself), and I almost gave this slot to her. But, Hilary eked this one out because of her Oscar wins, and also because of her roles in Amelia, PS I Love You, 11:14, and Freedom Writers.
1973
Neil Patrick Harris and Vera Farmiga
I know what you're thinking. Why in the world does Doogie Houser, MD get this award instead of, say, Adrien Brody (who has actually won an Oscar). Well, he gets it because I genuinely feel Neil is better. The man is openly gay, and yet somehow manages to convince me every week that he is a completely straight, horn-dog on How I Met Your Mother. Just because he hasn't done the big movies doesn't mean he couldn't. He's a theater guy, and also, it's rare when an openly gay man actually gets the chance to take on a leading film role...much less a role in a film that has Oscar potential. Straight men can play gay, but you won't see a gay man play straight.
Vera Farmiga is also not a huge movie star, or well-known...but she's my winner, beating out Juliette Lewis (who's received an Oscar nom) and Kate Beckinsale. But Vera wins for her fantastic work in Up in the Air, The Boy with the Striped Pajamas, and The Departed. If you haven't watch any of those films you should. But be warned, Striped Pajamas will depress you for a full day or longer.
1972
Jude Law and Toni Colette
Jude had only one real contender, and that was Ben Affleck. I know, there's not really a comparison, and perhaps if Ben had won his Oscar for acting instead of writing a screenplay, I could have given him more credence. But Jude has received two nominations, (Cold Mountain, The Talented Mr. Ripley). He's also starred in Closer, AI, Road to Perdition, The Aviator, The Holiday, Sherlock Holmes, and Repo Men, just to name a few. And he famously stepped in and helped finished The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus after Heath Ledger died in the middle of shooting the film.
Toni Collette almost didn't win this. I almost gave it to Gwyneth Paltrow, who won an Oscar for Shakespeare In Love. But I chose Toni for her ability to completely disappear into a role. She was nominated for an Oscar for her role as Haley Joel Osment's mom in The Sixth Sense, was brilliant in About a Boy, costarred in The Hours, shone in Little Miss Sunshine, was fantastic in Evening, and endearing in In Her Shoes. Probably her best role, though, is in her TV show The United States of Tara, in which she plays a schizophrenic, and has won an Emmy and Golden Globe for her performance.
1971
Mark Wahlberg and Winona Ryder
This one was difficult as well, because I had to consider Ewan McGregor and Taye Diggs (who, even though he doesn't have much of a movie career, is a brilliant actor nonetheless, especially on the stage). But Mark got the nod because of his wide variety of roles, including two Oscar nominations for The Departed and The Fighter. But I would be remiss if I didn't mention his breakthrough work in Fear, as well as his roles in action movies (Three Kings, The Italian Job, Shooter,) and dramas (Invincible, The Lovely Bones, The Perfect Storm,) and comedies (Date Night, The Other Guys). (I'm going to completely ignore Boogie Nights.)
Winona was a pretty easy choice, though I considered Emily Mortimer and Sanaa Lathan. Her work as a child actor, (Beetle Juice, Heathers, Great Balls of Fire) led to good work as a young adult which included two Oscar nominations (The Age of Innocence, Little Women) as well as Edward Scissorhands and How to Make an American Quilt. Then she starred in Girl, Interrupted, and Autumn in New York. And more recently has had supporting roles in Star Trek and Black Swan. Kleptomania aside, she's really fantastic.